sardonicynic: stock | fashion (Sarah - Witness)
swear that you should hear it ([personal profile] sardonicynic) wrote in [personal profile] melcreada 2007-08-02 07:38 pm (UTC)

a) *hugs*

b) ZOMG, parody FTW! I only had time to read the very first section and was already snorting to myself, hee!

c) *nods so much* Yes. Double-yes. Triple-yes to absolutely everything you said. Hedwig was the first of many blows to come. I didn't cry, only because my brain went into auto-denial mode there.

Dobby — oh god, Dobby. Y'know, it wasn't even his actual death that triggered the sobs (I was stupefied with horror and the terrible unfairness of it all); it was when Ron started taking off his shoes so Dobby could be buried with them. *breaks* And then everyone else began donating items of clothing. *breaks again*

Also, Fred? Oh, man. *meep* But! Here's my quasi-quibble: Did you feel like that was almost an unnecessarily harsh thing to do? Like, Rowling felt like she needed to kill someone in the inner circle for the sake of killing someone in the inner circle?

And yes, Snape and Lily and the unrequited love and the pain and the distance ground me (are still grinding me) into tiny pieces. I cannot wait to see Alan Rickman's performance because the man *is* Severus Snape. *g*

Ack, "the abandoned boys" — such a fantastic point and OMG, Neville! *bounces* AND HIS GRAN! *bounces some more*

All right. I have to stop or this comment will never end.

Post a comment in response:

This account has disabled anonymous posting.
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting